How to make mac and cheese soup
Researched by Abu Bakar Saadat5 min read
Last updated: 19 November 2026References

On this page 8 sections
In short
Cook elbow macaroni in 5 cups of broth until it's al dente. In a separate pan, make a butter-and-flour roux, whisk in the milk, then melt in cheddar, Parmesan and mozzarella with garlic powder and mustard powder. Pour the cheese sauce into the pasta and broth, then top it with cracked black pepper.

At a glance
Overview
Hello and welcome! This is mac and cheese you eat with a spoon. The pasta cooks in the broth and stays in it, and the cheese sauce turns that broth into soup. You need two pans: a large pot for the pasta and a saucepan for the sauce.
| Stage | Time or cue in Roshi's recipe |
|---|---|
| Pasta in broth | Boil, then cook until al dente, about 8–10 minutes |
| Roux (butter + flour) | Whisk constantly, about 1–2 minutes, until smooth and thickened |
| Milk | Add gradually, whisking all the time. It clumps at first, then smooths out |
| Cheeses + powders | Heat down to low, then mix until smooth |
| Combine | Pour the cheese sauce slowly into the pasta and broth |
Before you start
- Don't drain the pasta. The broth it cooks in becomes the soup.
- Grate all three cheeses before you start the roux. Once the milk is in, the sauce moves quickly.
- Keep a whisk handy. Roshi's method says to whisk constantly for the roux and the milk.
Ingredients
- Vegetable or chicken broth – 5 cups
- Elbow macaroni, uncooked – half a 500 g pack (250 g)
- Unsalted butter – ⅓ cup
- All-purpose flour – ¼ cup
- Milk – 1½ cups
- Sharp yellow cheddar cheese, grated – 2 cups
- Fresh Parmesan cheese, grated – ⅓ cup
- Mozzarella cheese, grated – ¼ cup
- Garlic powder – 1 teaspoon
- Mustard powder – 2 teaspoons
- Fresh green onions or parsley, finely chopped – for garnish
- Black pepper, freshly cracked – for garnish
Steps
Cook the pasta in the broth
Pour the broth into a large pot and bring it to a boil over medium-high heat. Add the macaroni and cook just until al dente, about 8–10 minutes. Set it aside without draining.
In the video (0:12 to 0:20): the broth goes into a steel pot first, then the macaroni is tipped in from a plate, and she stirs it with a wooden spoon.

Broth poured into the large pot. Photo: Roshi, from her video (0:10) 
Elbow macaroni tipped into the broth. Photo: Roshi, from her video (0:15) 
Stirring the macaroni as it cooks. Photo: Roshi, from her video (0:18) Make the roux
While the pasta is cooking, melt the butter in a large saucepan over medium heat. Add the flour and whisk constantly for about 1–2 minutes, until the roux is smooth and thickened.
In the video (0:22 to 0:28): the butter melts in a dark pan, then the flour goes in on top.

Butter goes into the saucepan. Photo: Roshi, from her video (0:21) 
Flour added to the melted butter. Photo: Roshi, from her video (0:26) 
Whisking the roux. Photo: Roshi, from her video (0:26) Whisk in the milk
Add the milk gradually, whisking constantly. The sauce will thicken and clump at first. Once you add more milk, it smooths out again.
In the video (0:30 to 0:35): after the first pour of milk the roux looks like yellow crumbs. More milk turns it into a smooth white sauce.

The roux clumps when the first milk goes in. Photo: Roshi, from her video (0:30) 
More milk, whisked smooth. Photo: Roshi, from her video (0:34) Add the cheeses and seasoning
Add the cheddar, Parmesan and mozzarella, and reduce the heat to low. Stir in the garlic powder and mustard powder. Mix well until smooth.
In the video (0:38 to 0:54): the grated cheese goes in, the two powders are sprinkled on top, and she folds it all together with a spatula until it turns into a thick, glossy sauce.

The grated cheeses go in. Photo: Roshi, from her video (0:39) 
Garlic powder and mustard powder on top. Photo: Roshi, from her video (0:46) 
Mixed into a thick, glossy cheese sauce. Photo: Roshi, from her video (0:52) Combine the sauce and the soup
Slowly pour the cheese mixture into the pot of macaroni and broth. Mix well until combined.
In the video (0:56 to 1:08): the thick sauce slides off the spatula into the pot in long, stretchy ribbons. After stirring, the broth turns creamy and pale.

The cheese sauce poured into the pasta and broth. Photo: Roshi, from her video (0:57) 
Stirred together into a creamy soup. Photo: Roshi, from her video (1:06) Garnish and serve
Garnish with chopped green onions or parsley, and cracked black pepper.
In the video (0:00 and 1:10 onwards): the finished bowl is topped with small green leaves and cracked black pepper.

Garnished with green herbs and cracked black pepper. Photo: Roshi, from her video (1:08) 
A spoonful of mac and cheese soup. Photo: Roshi, from her video (1:14)
Common mistakes
- Adding all the milk at once. Roshi adds it gradually and whisks constantly.
- Panicking when the sauce clumps. Her recipe says it clumps at first and smooths out as more milk goes in.
- Draining the pasta. The broth is the base of the soup.
If this doesn't work
- The sauce is still lumpy after the first splash of milk: keep adding milk slowly and keep whisking. Her recipe says it smooths out again.
- The cheese isn't fully mixed in: keep the heat on low and keep stirring until it's smooth, as Roshi's step 4 says.
Storing leftovers
The Food Standards Agency says leftovers should be in the fridge no more than two hours after cooking, and eaten within two days (48 hours) or frozen. When you reheat, make it steaming hot throughout, and only reheat it once.
More recipes from Roshi
- How to make potato and vegetable samosas
- How to make chana masala
- How to make chicken tikka masala
- How to make butter chicken
That's it! A bowl of cheesy, spoonable comfort. Make it, tell us how it went, and follow us for Roshi's next recipe.
Sources and method
- Researched by
- Abu Bakar Saadat
- Tested by our team
- No. We have no record of anyone on our team trying these steps, so treat them as researched instructions from the sources below.
- Pictures
- 16 illustrations drawn for this article: drawings, not photos.
Did this solve the problem?
Where did you get stuck?
What did you think?
Reaction counts are loading.


